嗔秤戻幣�哉膵�云利匈嬉蝕湊蛸賜�塋床四衲���萩晦編報炎嘔囚^泡仟 ̄云利匈�《超噌�殻窟�嵌虜隆輓麈觚翹瀘卉韮�仍仍�。� 烏御危列
湘弼慕汐 卦指云慕朕村 厘議慕尺 厘議慕禰 TXT畠云和墮 序秘慕杏 紗秘慕禰

alexandria and her schools(冉煽表寄才慢議僥丕)-及6嫗

梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ○ 賜 ★ 辛酔堀貧和鍬匈��梓囚徒貧議 Enter 囚辛指欺云慕朕村匈��梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ● 辛指欺云匈競何��
!!!!隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��




For Antony having become possessor of it by right of the stronger�察�gave it 

to Cleopatra�察�and it remained at Alexandria for seven hundred years。                     But 

we must not anticipate events。 

     Then there must be besides a Mouseion�察�a Temple of the Muses�察�with 

all due appliances�察�in a vast building adjoining the palace itself�察�under the 

very    wing    of  royalty�察   �and   it  must   have    porticos�察  �wherein     sages   may 

converse�察�lecture´rooms�察�where they may display themselves at their will 

to their rapt scholars�察�each like a turkey´cock before his brood�察�and a large 

dining´hall�察  �where   they   may   enjoy   themselves   in   moderation�察  �as   befits 

sages�察�not without puns and repartees�察�epigrams�察�anagrams�察�and Attic salt�察�



                                                17 


´ Page 18´

                            ALEXANDRIA AND HER SCHOOLS 



to be fatal�察�alas�察�to poor Diodorus the dialectician。              For Stilpo�察�prince of 

sophists�察�having silenced him by some quibbling puzzle of logic�察�Ptolemy 

surnamed   him  Chronos   the   Slow。         Poor   Diodorus   went   home�察 �took   pen 

and ink�察�wrote a treatise on the awful nothing�察�and died in despair�察�leaving 

five ;dialectical daughters; behind him�察�to be thorns in the sides of some 

five hapless men of Macedonia�察�as ;emancipated women�察─�a class but too 

common in the later days of Greece�察�as they will always be�察�perhaps�察�in 

civilisations   which   are   decaying   and   crumbling   to   pieces�察  �leaving   their 

members to seek in bewilderment what they are�察�and what bonds connect 

them  with   their   fellow´beings。       But   to   return�此  �funds   shall   be   provided 

for the Museum from the treasury�察�a priest of rank�察�appointed by royalty�察�

shall    be   curator�察  �botanical    and   zoological     gardens    shall   be   attached�察�

collections     of   wonders     made。     In   all  things    the  presiding    genius    of 

Aristotle shall be worshipped�察�for these�察�like Alexander�察�were his pupils。 

Had he not mapped out all heaven and earth�察�things seen and unseen�察�with 

his   entelechies�察  �and   energies�察  �and   dunameis�察  �and   put   every   created   and 

uncreated   thing   henceforth   into   its   proper   place�察  �from   the   ascidians   and 

polypes of the sea to the virtues and the vicesyea�察�to that Great Deity and 

Prime Cause ��which indeed was all things���察�Noesis Noeseon�察 �the Thought 

of Thoughts�察─�whom he discovered by irrefragable processes of logic�察�and 

in whom the philosophers believe privately�察�leaving Serapis to the women 

and   the   sailors�拭   �All   they  had   to do   was   to   follow in   his   steps�察  �to   take 

each of them a branch�察�of science or literature�察�or as many branches as one 

man   conveniently  can�察  �and   working   them  out on   the   approved   methods�察�

end in a few years�察�as Alexander did�察�by weeping on the utmost shore of 

creation that there are no more worlds left to conquer。 

     Alas�   �the   Muses   are   shy   and   wild�察  �and   though   they   will   haunt�察  �like 

skylarks�察�on the bleakest northern moor as cheerfully as on the sunny hills 

of Greece�察�and rise thence singing into the heaven of heavens�察�yet they are 

hard to tempt into a gilded cage�察�however amusingly made and plentifully 

stored   with   comforts。      Royal   societies�察  �associations   of   savants�察  �and   the 

like�察�are good for many things�察�but not for the breeding of art and genius�此�

for they are things which cannot be bred。 Such institutions are  excellent 

for physical science�察�when�察�as among us now�察�physical science is going on 



                                                18 


´ Page 19´

                             ALEXANDRIA AND HER SCHOOLS 



the right method�此       �but where�察�as in Alexandria�察�it was going on an utterly 

wrong method�察�they stereotype the errors of the age�察�and invest them with 

the   prestige   of   authority�察  �and   produce   mere   Sorbonnes�察  �and   schools   of 

pedants。      To literature�察�too�察�they do some good�察�that is�察�in a literary age 

an   age   of   reflection   rather   than   of   production�察  �of   antiquarian   research�察�

criticism�察     �imitation�察   �when      book´making        has    become       an   easy    and 

respectable pursuit for the many who cannot dig�察�and are ashamed to beg。 

And yet�察�by adding that same prestige of authority�察�not to mention of good 

society and Court favour�察�to the popular mania for literature�察�they help on 

the growing evil�察�and increase the multitude of prophets who prophesy out 

of their own heart and have seen nothing。 

     And   this   was�察  �it   must   be   said�察  �the   outcome   of   all   the   Ptolemaean 

appliances。 

     In Physics they did little。         In Art nothing。        In Metaphysics less than 

nothing。 

     We will first examine�察�as the more pleasant spectacle of the two�察�that 

branch of thought in which some progress was really made�察�and in which 

the Ptolemaic schools helped forward the development of men who have 

become   world´famous�察  �and   will   remain   so�察  �I   suppose�察  �until   the   end   of 

time。 

     Four     names    at  once    attract   us�此  �Euclid�察   �Aristarchus�察     �Eratosthenes�察�

Hipparchus。        Archimedes�察�also�察�should be included in the list�察�for he was 

a   pupil   of   the   Alexandrian   school�察  �having   studied   ��if   Proclus   is   to   be 

trusted��   in   Egypt�察  �under   Conon   the   Samian�察  �during          the   reigns   of   two 

Ptolemies�察�Philadelphus and Euergetes。 

     Of   Euclid�察  �as   the   founder   ��according   to   Proclus��   of   the Alexandrian 

Mathematical   school�察 �I   must   of   course speak   first。         Those   who   wish   to 

attain   to   a   juster   conception   of   the   man   and   his   work   than   they   can   do 

from     any    other   source�察   �will   do   well   to  read    Professor    De    Morgan's 

admirable article on him in ;Smith's Classical Dictionary�察─�which includes�察�

also�察   �a  valuable     little  sketch   of   the   rise  of  Geometric       science�察   �from 

Pythagoras   and   Plato�察  �of   whose   school   Euclid   was�察  �to   the   great   master 

himself。 

     I shall   confine   myself   to   one observation   on  Euclid's   genius�察 �and   on 



                                                 19 


´ Page 20´

                            ALEXANDRIA AND HER SCHOOLS 



the immense influence which it exerted on after generations。                    It seems to 

me�察  �speaking   under   correction�察  �that   it   exerted   this�察  �because   it   was     so 

complete   a   type   of   the   general   tendency   of   the   Greek   mind�察  �deductive�察�

rather    than   inductive�察   �of  unrivalled     subtlety   in  obtaining     results   from 

principles�察  �and   results   again   from   them   ad   infinitum�此     �deficient   in   that 

sturdy moral patience which is required for the examination of facts�察�and 

which   has   made   Britain   at   once   a   land   of   practical   craftsmen�察  �and   of 

earnest scientific discoverers。 

     Volatile�察�restless�察 �always children longing for something new�察─�as the 

Egyptian priest said of them�察�they were too ready to believe that they had 

attained   laws�察  �and   then�察  �tired   with   their   toy�察  �throw   away   those   hastily 

assumed laws�察�and wander off in search of others。                 Gifted�察�beyond all the 

sons of men�察�with the most exquisite perception of form�察�both physical and 

metaphysical�察�they could become geometers and logicians as they became 

sculptors     and   artists�察  �beyond    that   they   could    hardly   rise。   The     were 

conscious of their power to build�察�and it made them ashamed to dig。 

     Four men only among them seem�察�as far as I can judge�察�to have had a 

great   inductive   power�此     �Socrates   and   Plato   in   Metaphysics�察�Archimedes 

and   Hipparchus   in   Physics。        But   these   men   ran   so   far   counter   to   the 

national genius�察�that their examples were not followed。                  As you will hear 

presently�察�the discoveries of Archimedes and Hipparchus were allowed to 

remain      where    they   were    for   centuries。     The    Dialectic     of  Plato   and 

Socrates      was   degraded      into   a  mere    art  for   making     anything     appear 

alternately true and false�察�and among the Megaric school�察�for undermining 

the ground of all science�察�and paving the way for scepticism�察�by denying 

the    natural   world    to  be   the   object   of  certain    knowledge。       The    only 

element of Plato's thought to which they clung was�察�as we shall find from 

the    Neoplatonists�察     �his  physical     speculations�察    �in  which�察    �deserting    his 

inductive method�察�he has fallen below himself into the popular cacoethes�察�

and     Pythagorean      deductive      dreams     about    the  mysterious      powers
卦指朕村 貧匯匈 和匯匈 指欺競何 壘��0�� 家��0��
隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��
梁椣戻幣�� 梁心弌傍議揖扮窟燕得胎��傍竃徭失議心隈才凪万弌誌育断蛍�輌臆惨軼僑〃�燕慕得珊辛參資誼持蛍才将刮襲潜��範寔亟圻幹慕得 瓜寡追葎娼得辛參資誼寄楚署衛、持蛍才将刮襲潜填��