嗔秤戻幣�哉膵�云利匈嬉蝕湊蛸賜�塋床四衲���萩晦編報炎嘔囚^泡仟 ̄云利匈�《超噌�殻窟�嵌虜隆輓麈觚翹瀘卉韮�仍仍�。� 烏御危列
湘弼慕汐 卦指云慕朕村 厘議慕尺 厘議慕禰 TXT畠云和墮 序秘慕杏 紗秘慕禰

alexandria and her schools(冉煽表寄才慢議僥丕)-及29嫗

梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ○ 賜 ★ 辛酔堀貧和鍬匈��梓囚徒貧議 Enter 囚辛指欺云慕朕村匈��梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ● 辛指欺云匈競何��
!!!!隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��




the    Koreish�察    �receded     in   the   minds     of   their   descendants      to   an 

unapproachable and abysmal distance。             For they had lost the sense of His 

present    guidance�察   �His   personal    care。   They     had   lost  all  which   could 

connect Him with the working of their own souls�察�with their human duties 

and struggles�察�with the belief that His mercy and love were counterparts of 

human mercy and human love�察�in plain English�察�that He was loving and 

merciful at all。 The change came very gradually�察�thank God�察�you may read 



                                              88 


´ Page 89´

                            ALEXANDRIA AND HER SCHOOLS 



of   noble    sayings    and   deeds   here   and   there�察  �for  many     centuries   after 

Mohammed�此         �but it came�察�and then their belief in God's omnipotence and 

absoluteness   dwindled   into   the   most   dark�察  �and   slavish�察  �and   benumbing 

fatalism。       His     unchangeableness        became      in   their    minds     not   an 

unchangeable purpose to teach�察�forgive�察�and deliver menas it seemed to 

Mohammed   to   have   been   but   a   mere   brute   necessity�察  �an   unchangeable 

purpose to have His own way�察�whatsoever that way might be。                      That dark 

fatalism�察�also�察�has helped toward the decay of the Mohammedan nations。 

It has made them careless of self´improvement�察�faithless of the possibility 

of progress�察�and has kept�察�and will keep�察�the Mohammedan nations�察�in all 

intellectual matters�察�whole ages behind the Christian nations of the West。 

     How far the story of Omar's commanding the baths of Alexandria to be 

heated with the books from the great library is true�察�we shall never know。 

Some       have    doubted      the   story    altogether�此     �but     so   many      fresh 

corroborations   of   it   are   said   to   have   been   lately   discovered�察  �in   Arabic 

writers�察�that I can hardly doubt that it had some foundation in fact。 One 

cannot     but  believe    that  John    Philoponus�察    �the  last  of  the   Alexandrian 

grammarians�察�when he asked his patron Amrou the gift of the library�察�took 

care to save some�察�at least�察�of its treasures�察�and howsoever strongly Omar 

may   have   felt   or   said   that   all   books   which   agreed   with   the   Koran   were 

useless�察  �and    all  which    disagreed    with   it  only   fit  to  be  destroyed�察  �the 

general feeling of the Mohammedan leaders was very different。                     As they 

settled in the various countries which they conquered�察�education seems to 

have been considered by them an important object。                   We even find some 

of   them�察   �in  the  same    generation     as  Mohammed�察       �obeying     strictly  the 

Prophet's   command   to   send   all   captive   children   to   schoola   fact   which 

speaks as well for the Mussulmans' good sense�察�as it speaks ill for the state 

of education among the degraded descendants of the Greek conquerors of 

the East。     Gradually philosophic Schools arose�察�first at Bagdad�察�and then 

at Cordova�察�and the Arabs carried on the task of commenting on Aristotle's 

Logic�察�and Ptolemy's Megiste Syntaxiswhich last acquired from them the 

name   of   Almagest�察  �by   which   it   was   so   long   known   during   the   Middle 

Ages。 

     But they did little but comment�察�though there was no Neoplatonic or 



                                               89 


´ Page 90´

                            ALEXANDRIA AND HER SCHOOLS 



mystic   element   in   their   commentaries。        It   seems   as   if   Alexandria   was 

preordained�察�by its very central position�察�to be the city of commentators�察�

not of originators。       It is worthy of remark�察�that Philoponus�察�who may be 

considered   as   the   man   who   first   introduced   the   simple   warriors   of   the 

Koreish   to   the   treasures   of   Greek   thought�察  �seems   to   have   been   the   first 

rebel against the Neoplatonist eclecticism。             He maintained�察�and truly�察�that 

Porphyry�察     �Proclus�察  �and    the  rest�察 �had   entirely   misunderstood       Aristotle�察�

when     they   attempted     to  reconcile    him    with   Plato�察  �or  incorporate     his 

philosophy   into      Platonism。     Aristotle   was    henceforth   the   text´book      of 

Arab savants。       It was natural enough。        The Mussulman mind was trained 

in   habits   of   absolute   obedience   to   the   authority   of   fixed   dogmas。    All 

those   attempts   to   follow   out   metaphysic   to   its   highest   object�察  �theology�察�

would   be   useless   if   not   wrong   in   the   eyes   of   a   Mussulman�察  �who   had 

already his simple and sharply´defined creed on all matters relating to the 

unseen   world。       With   him   metaphysic   was   a   study   altogether   divorced 

from man's higher life and aspirations。 So also were physics。                  What need 

had he of Cosmogonies�拭�what need to trace the relations between man and 

the universe�察�or the universe and its Maker�拭             �He had his definite material 

Elysium and Tartarus�察�as the only ultimate relation between man and the 

universe�察�his dogma of an absolute fiat�察�creating arbitrary and once for all�察�

as   the only  relation   between the universe   and its   Maker�此          �and   further  it 

was not lawful to speculate。          The idea which I believe unites both physic 

and metaphysic with man's highest inspirations and widest speculations 

the Alexandria idea of the Logos�察�of the Deity working in time and space 

by successive thoughtshe had not heard of�察�for it was dead�察�as I have said�察�

in Alexandria itself�察�and if he had heard of it�察�he would have spurned it as 

detracting from the absoluteness of that abysmal one Being�察�of whom he 

so nobly yet so partially bore witness。            So it was to be�察�doubtless it was 

right that it should be so。        Man's eye is too narrow to see a whole truth�察�

his brain too weak to carry a whole truth。              Better for him�察�and better for 

the world�察�is perhaps the method on which man has been educated in every 

age�察�by which to each school�察�or party�察�or nation�察�is given some one great 

truth�察�which they are to work out to its highest development�察�to exemplify 

in actual life�察�leaving some happier age perhaps�察�alas� �only some future 



                                               90 


´ Page 91´

                            ALEXANDRIA AND HER SCHOOLS 



stateto   reconcile   that   too   favoured   dogma   with   other   truths   which   lie 

beside    it�察 �and   without    which    it  is  always   incomplete�察    �and   sometimes 

altogether barren。 

     But such schools of science�察�founded on such a ground as this�察�on the 

mere instinct of curiosity�察�had little chance of originality or vitality。               All 

the    great    schools    of   the   world�察   �the   elder    Greek     philosophy�察    �the 

Alexandrian�察�the present   Baconian   school   of physics�察�have  had   a  deeper 

motive for their search�察�a far higher object which they hope to discover。 

But indeed�察�the Mussulmans did not so much wish to discover truth�察�as to 

cultivate     their  own    intellects。    For    that  purpose     a  sharp   and    subtle 

systematist�察  �like   Aristotle�察  �was   the   very   man   whom   they   required�察  �and 

from   the   destruction   of Alexandria   may   date   the   rise   of   the Aristotelian 

philosophy。      Translations of his works were made into Arabic�察�first�察�it is 

said�察�from Persian and Syriac translations�察�the former of which had been 

made      during    the  sixth   and   seventh     centuries�察   �by  the   wreck     of  the 

Neoplatonist   party�察     �during   their  visit   to  the   philosophic   Chozroos。      A 

century   after�察  �they   filled   Alexandria。     After   them   Almansoor�察  �Hairoun 

Alraschid�察�and their successors�察�who patronised the Nestorian Christians�察�

obtained      from    them     translations    of   the   philosophic�察     �medical�察    �and 

astronomical Greek works�察�while the last of the Omniades�察�Abdalrahman�察�

had introduced the same literary taste into Spain�察�where�察�in the thirteenth 

century�察�Averroes and Maimonides rivalled the fame of Avicenna�察�who had 

flourished at Bagdad a century before。 

     But�察�as I have said already�察�these Arabs seem to have invented nothing�察�

they only commented。           And yet not only commented�察�for they preserved 

for    us  those   works     of  whose     real  value    they   were    so  little  aware。 

Averroes�察�in quality of commentator on Aristotle�察�became his rival in the 

minds of the mediaeval schoolmen�察�Avicenna�察�in quality of commentator 

on Hippocrates and Galen�察�was for centuries the text´book of all European 

physicians�察  �while Albatani   and Aboul Wefa�察 �as   astronomers�察  �commented 

on Ptolemy�察�not however without making a few important
卦指朕村 貧匯匈 和匯匈 指欺競何 壘��0�� 家��0��
隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��
梁椣戻幣�� 梁心弌傍議揖扮窟燕得胎��傍竃徭失議心隈才凪万弌誌育断蛍�輌臆惨軼僑〃�燕慕得珊辛參資誼持蛍才将刮襲潜��範寔亟圻幹慕得 瓜寡追葎娼得辛參資誼寄楚署衛、持蛍才将刮襲潜填��